BLOG

Newsletter Vol. 39: The Need for Hope & REALITIES OF PAIN

March 1, 2022

●

4 min

Butterfly on a Sunflower at the McKee-Beshers Wildlife Management Area, Maryland

The Optimistic Anthropologist · Volume 039 · March 2022

MARCH 2022 | VOLUME 39

Dear Reader,

The Gulf War was the first war I remember witnessing on television. I was 11 years old and I cried watching the images of the U.S. dropping bombs at night over Kuwait. If it was that scary for me watching in safety from 6,743 miles away, how terrifying must it have been for those experiencing it?

My partner Emir grew up in the four year-long siege of his home city of Sarajevo during which regular citizens -- much like today’s Ukrainians – took up arms to defend themselves and their families and their city and their newly independent country from invading forces. He recently wrote a short essay about the home he grew up in reflecting, “our apartment is on the basement level. Actually, quite handy when you’re continuously bombarded night after night but are not facing any of the enemy positions besieging your city directly. I keep thinking about what it’s like in spaces like this one tonight in Kyiv and everywhere else in Ukraine.”

Wars end, but for the people who experience them, they live on in their minds and bodies, their families and homes and cities forever. Memories - both painful and hopeful - resurface with each new conflict in the world.

In recent days, I have been moved by and struggled with watching the veneration of the Ukranian citizens’ resistance to Russia’s invasion. But this didn’t fully click until I read a thread that Dr. Aditi Nerurkar wrote, “I want to caution us against glorifying the trauma of the Ukrainian people. Highlighting the resilience of Ukrainians is extremely important to boost morale but let’s not paint a caricature at the expense of their mental health. They are rightfully, deeply suffering right now.”

I’m not surprised that people who have never experienced war often do not know how to talk about or engage with its realities fully or thoughtfully. Whereas people who have survived it or work closely with those who have, often talk about the need for hope and the realities of pain. One of the most powerful examples I have heard and read of this is Aida Cerkez’s letter to the people of Ukraine. Cerkez is a Bosnian journalist who survived the Siege of Sarajevo and her powerful letter is a mix of reflection and warning to the people of Ukraine, acknowledging of the pains and indignities that they are experiencing, the need to record what is happening for history and accountability, and noting that “you will lose faith sometimes. I am writing to you from the future, you will prevail, just as we did.”

I share all this because we live in a world of thought leaders and talking heads and expertise earned by university degree. And while these things do have value, well-read thinkers and speakers alone are not sufficient to ensure our full understanding of war and our world’s many other complex problems. We need for the people closest to these problems -- who truly understand the hope and the pain of these problems -- to not just be heard and listened to by the powerful (which is all of us), but also for their messages and lessons to be felt so deeply that we will do the work to collectively change ourselves, our institutions, and our systems.

Alison Gold

Be well, do good, and keep each other safe,
Alison

P.S. I always welcome your feedback on these newsletters.

P.P.S. I also enjoy learning with and from you about your work. Click here to schedule a time.

LATEST

RENT OUR 2BR/2.5 BA HOUSE IN WASHINGTON, DC FOR SUMMER 2022

  • relocating to DC and wanting a place to land

  • coming to DC for work or research for summer 2022;

  • wanting to explore DC neighborhood living for a summer.

JOB, RFP, AND FELLOWSHIP ROUND-UP FOR JANUARY & FEBRUARY 2022

Folks we know are recruiting for a lot of cool things! Each month, we share The Right People on the Bus, a monthly-ish round-up of job, consulting, and fully- funded fellowship and accelerator opportunities that people and organizations connected to Optimistic Anthropology are recruiting for. Check out the latest!

If you have other opportunities that you’d like us to include in the future, submit them here (our list reaches ~1300 great people!)

WHAT WILL IT TAKE TO SHAPE COMMUNITIES & NATIONS THAT SUPPORT ALL PEOPLE TO GRIEVE, HEAL, AND THRIVE?

It’s been a long year, and it’s only the start of its third month. Back in December, our founder Alison Gold asked “What will it take to share communities and nations that support all people to grieve, heal, and thrive?” Not because she knows the answers, but because she’s seeking to connect with others wanting to imagine and work toward the answers. Given all that’s going on in the world, we thought it was worth re-sharing the question and the call to connect!

GOOD LISTENS FROM JANUARY/FEBRUARY 2022

We love music, podcasts, and audiobooks! And we see connections between all kinds of culture and the work we do. We’ve been listening to more novels lately, so the list is shorter.

MOST POPULAR IN JANUARY / FEBRUARY 2022

ABOUT OPTIMISTIC ANTHROPOLOGY

Optimistic Anthropology helps organizations and cross-sector collaborations trying to solve some of the world’s toughest problems “learn into” equitable, just, and positive institutional and systemic change.

Learn more about OA here. Cooking up something and could use our help? Schedule time to chat with Alison.

Connect with Optimistic Anthropology

Read the original newsletter

Comments

Subscribe to Optimistic Anthropology Newsletter

Sign up for a periodic field report from Optimistic Anthropology—featuring fresh blog posts, events worth your time, new additions to our resource collection, updates on what we're up to, and an occasional photo of our office mascot, Dimi the wonderdog!

Shaping knowledge, process, and culture for a more positive future.

All photos are by Alison Gold, unless noted otherwise. Content on this website is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 License. For permissions, visit https://www.optimisticanthro.com/contact-us.

Made by

Subscribe to Optimistic Anthropology Newsletter

Sign up for a periodic field report from Optimistic Anthropology—featuring fresh blog posts, events worth your time, new additions to our resource collection, updates on what we're up to, and an occasional photo of our office mascot, Dimi the wonderdog!

Shaping knowledge, process, and culture for a more positive future.

All photos are by Alison Gold, unless noted otherwise. Content on this website is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 License. For permissions, visit https://www.optimisticanthro.com/contact-us.

Made by

Subscribe to Optimistic Anthropology Newsletter

Sign up for a periodic field report from Optimistic Anthropology—featuring fresh blog posts, events worth your time, new additions to our resource collection, updates on what we're up to, and an occasional photo of our office mascot, Dimi the wonderdog!

Shaping knowledge, process, and culture for a more positive future.

All photos are by Alison Gold, unless noted otherwise. Content on this website is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 License. For permissions, visit https://www.optimisticanthro.com/contact-us.

Made by