BLOG

Newsletter Vol. 41: Repairing That Hole in the Universe

October 1, 2022

●

4 min

Bosnian coffee cups, part of the installation Što te Nema by Aida Šehović, Sarajevo, Bosnia-Herzegovina

The Optimistic Anthropologist · Volume 041 · October 2022

OCTOBER 2022 | VOLUME 41

Dear Reader,

As I look back over the last year, and particularly the last couple of months when I was living overseas in Sarajevo, I’m struck by how the themes of remembrance, reckoning, repentance, and repair came up so often in things I had the chance to experience and engage with. And how often these concepts feel so painfully elusive in the world today.

One example of this was at a talk I attended by the Bosnian artist Aida Šehović. Šehović created Što Te Nema as a performance in the Baščaršija (old town) of Sarajevo on July 11, 2006 to honor and remember the 8,372 victims of the Srebrenica Genocide. Before undertaking this project, Šehović reached out to and built relationships with some of the Mothers of

Srebrenica, themselves victims of the genocide, and together they collected 932 Bosnian coffee cups (and continues to be in relationship with the mothers today). At the performance, the artist set out the cups and filled them with Bosnian coffee to honor the Bosnian Muslim men and boys who would never come home to participate in the daily ritual of drinking coffee with family and friends. For 14 years, diaspora communities across the U.S. and Europe invited Šehović to assemble and disassemble the monument on July 11, and people have continued to contribute their coffee cups to the project (there were 9,909 as of the day I saw her speak). Over the years, the process of the performance also evolved so that anyone can participate in laying out the cups and pouring the coffee.

Since the first time I saw it, Što Te Nema struck me as a powerful example of communal connection and remembrance about a deeply painful event for which there has been no repentance or repair. While International Tribunals and Courts have deemed what happened in Srebrenica a genocide and found key leaders guilty of that crime and others, genocide denial is rampant in the region (and the world) and perpetrators continue to be celebrated. Tribunals and Courts don’t change people’s behavior or heal the harm done to victims.

Recently, I was listening to an interview with Rabbi Danya Ruttenberg about her new book On Repentance and Repair: Making Amends in an Unapologetic World. In the interview, she stated, “I believe that real repentance work…focuses on the needs of the person, people, community who’s harmed. And is about taking care of them and is about repairing that hole in the universe. Pushing forgiveness is telling the person who was harmed that you need to basically let go of this horrible thing that was done to you, even though nobody is taking care of you, even though nobody is attending to your needs.”

She went on to explain how the 12th century philosopher and Torah scholar Maimonides analyzed and synthesized pre-existing Jewish teachings on “teshuvah, usually translated as repentance, [but] really means return…It’s about coming back to your integrity, your sense of self, your best self… It’s about acting like you have a family, like you’re accountable to people, and like you matter.”

Maimonides identified five distinct steps in this process (which I’ll distill in a very un-nuanced way) to: 1) own the harm that you caused fully and completely; 2) start to change; 3) make amends (based on what the victim wants or needs); 4) apologize (and you may or may not be forgiven, as repentance and forgiveness are separate things); and 5) change your behavior and make different choices when in similar situations.

In this framing, the process of return takes time and effort, and apology only comes after a person or people have owned their impact, begun to change, and made amends. Beyond the individual, this process is critical to the work of community, institutional, national, and systemic transformation. Yet, seldom do we require those who have caused harm to recognize their impact, let alone reckon, repent, and repair in this way.

Which makes me wonder, what would our world, our nation, our institutions, our communities look like if we did reckon, repent, and repair in this way? What will it take - individually and collectively - to return?

Alison Gold

Be well, do good, and keep each other safe,
Alison

P.S. If you’ve seen or experienced examples of reckoning, repentance, and repair in your community or systems change work, I’d love to learn from and with you. I welcome and invite your stories and comments and questions and critiques.

P.P.S. I have the capacity to take on some additional work in 2023. Over the last couple of years, I’ve loved delving deeper into equitable evaluation and working with teams to strengthen their approaches to systems change and deep equity. If that sounds like something you may need, please email me and/or schedule a time to chat.

LATEST

SEEKING GUEST SPEAKERS FOR SPRING SEMESTER CLASS ON MULTI-SECTOR STRATEGIC PARTNERSHIPS

Starting in January 2023, Alison Gold will be teaching Multi-Sector Strategic Partnerships (with a focus on systemic change) at the Presidio Graduate School for the fourth time! Her students always rave about guest speakers who share about their work in MSPs and how it has related to themes in the course focused on: 1) people and purpose, 2) structure and strategy, 3) funding and casemaking, and 4) learning and accountability.

We’ve had an amazing array of guest speakers in the past and always are looking to feature new folks too! Interested in helping build the field of multi-sector partnership practitioners for the future? Or have a suggestion of someone who’d be a great guest speaker for MBA/MPA students committed to climate action and social justice? Email Alison!

SUMMER/FALL 2022 ROUND-UP OF SOCIAL CHANGE JOBS, RFPS, AND FELLOWSHIPS

Folks we know are recruiting for A LOT of great jobs this fall all across the U.S.! Each newsletter, we share The Right People on the Bus, a monthly-ish round-up of job, consulting, and fully- funded fellowship and accelerator opportunities that people and organizations connected to Optimistic Anthropology are recruiting for. Check out the latest!

If you have other opportunities that you’d like us to include in the future, submit them here (our list reaches ~1300 great people!)

COMING TO DC? WE’D LOVE TO HOST YOU AT THE GARDEN APARTMENT!

The Garden Apartment at Optimism House is a colorful and quiet private 1 bedroom apartment for people who are visiting DC while they engage in activism, conferences, travel, work, or study. We’ve hosted amazing guests from all over the world. We recently were certified as an Air BnB Superhost, and our cleaning fees support a neighbor. We have some availability remaining for this year from November 27 - January 2.

GOOD LISTENS FROM SUMMER/EARLY FALL 2022

We love music, podcasts, and audiobooks! And we see connections between all kinds of culture and the work we do.

MOST POPULAR POSTS IN 2022


WHAT THE HECK IS EMERGENT STRATEGY?

5 QUESTIONS TO ASK & ANSWER WHEN PRACTICING COMMUNITY ENGAGEMENT


WHAT THE HECK IS EMERGENT LEARNING?

ABOUT OPTIMISTIC ANTHROPOLOGY

Optimistic Anthropology helps organizations and cross-sector collaborations trying to solve some of the world’s toughest problems “learn into” equitable, just, and positive institutional and systemic change.

Learn more about OA here. Cooking up something and could use our help? Schedule time to chat with Alison.

Connect with Optimistic Anthropology

Read the original newsletter

Comments

Subscribe to Optimistic Anthropology Newsletter

Sign up for a periodic field report from Optimistic Anthropology—featuring fresh blog posts, events worth your time, new additions to our resource collection, updates on what we're up to, and an occasional photo of our office mascot, Dimi the wonderdog!

Shaping knowledge, process, and culture for a more positive future.

All photos are by Alison Gold, unless noted otherwise. Content on this website is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 License. For permissions, visit https://www.optimisticanthro.com/contact-us.

Made by

Subscribe to Optimistic Anthropology Newsletter

Sign up for a periodic field report from Optimistic Anthropology—featuring fresh blog posts, events worth your time, new additions to our resource collection, updates on what we're up to, and an occasional photo of our office mascot, Dimi the wonderdog!

Shaping knowledge, process, and culture for a more positive future.

All photos are by Alison Gold, unless noted otherwise. Content on this website is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 License. For permissions, visit https://www.optimisticanthro.com/contact-us.

Made by

Subscribe to Optimistic Anthropology Newsletter

Sign up for a periodic field report from Optimistic Anthropology—featuring fresh blog posts, events worth your time, new additions to our resource collection, updates on what we're up to, and an occasional photo of our office mascot, Dimi the wonderdog!

Shaping knowledge, process, and culture for a more positive future.

All photos are by Alison Gold, unless noted otherwise. Content on this website is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 License. For permissions, visit https://www.optimisticanthro.com/contact-us.

Made by